What Are We Doing? (Social Media* = Reality Distortion)

I was just scrolling on TikTok. I’m not proud of it. I still scroll on TikTok from time to time to try and promote an app I made. I feel the need to promote websites and apps that I make because if I’m the only one that knows about them that’s pretty boring. However, the app I attempt to promote on TikTok isn’t growing and so this may be a good time to finally give up TikTok for good. It would be best for my health.

Each time I’m on TikTok, minutes into scrolling I think, “What am I doing?” Or, “What are all of these people doing?” It’s obvious they’re making silly video clips, but I don’t think people always know why they are doing it. They just kind of get sucked in.

The majority of the videos are blatant cries for A) attention, and/or B) money. And I’m a hypocrite for continuing to be on TikTok. Which makes me a little bummed on one hand, but on the other hand all humans are hypocrites. It’s extraordinarily difficult to never be a hypocrite. Yes, <a href="https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10510506/">there have been studies</a>.

There have also been plenty of studies about the negative effects of social media. But, more than any other types, *I think short form video is the most unhealthy and causes significant reality distortion. Other types can be okay in moderation. I even founded and maintain what some may call social media. I prefer to call them online communities. Also, none of my community websites/apps have video because of what I’m discussing here (and storage/bandwidth issues to be honest).

Originally, I was going to say that short form video causes some sort of psychosis but I’ll admit that’s a stretch. Reality distortion is far more likely. Psychosis would be actual hallucinations or delusions whereas reality distortion is someone’s perception of the world becoming shaped by misinformation, conspiracy theories, algorithmic reinforcement, and confirmation bias.

When you look at this definition of reality distortion I think it’s pretty clear that short form video social media causes heavy distortion. You’re constantly swiping from short video to short video and most videos have filters and effects. If they don’t have filters or effects then it’s a person sucking in their gut, wearing a lot of makeup, or saying that some product is amazing whether they believe it or not. But on top of all of that, I also believe it’s easier to distort someone’s reality through video. Video can be much more realistic and persuasive compared to plain text or even still images.

<a href="https://academic.oup.com/jcmc/article/26/6/301/6336055">This study</a> (and there are many others) found that people were more likely to believe fabricated stories when they were presented as videos versus text or images.

Beyond scientific evidence, to me, this seems like common sense as well. If you have real looking people moving around and talking very similar to how an interaction would be face to face, then the brain is going to more easily think what it is interpreting is real. Even if it’s satire, racist, or some sort of propaganda.

If I see enough videos of people being cruel, I can start to feel like people are generally cruel. If everyone seems rich, my perfectly decent life starts looking like a failure. If strangers keep explaining that some ordinary habit is a sign of a serious problem, I might start looking for that problem in myself.

Plus, my feed isn’t a fair survey of the entire world. It’s a selection influenced by what I’ve watched, paused on, and interacted with. If something bothers me enough to keep watching, I may get more of it. Meanwhile, from my side of the screen, it can feel like I’m discovering that this thing is everywhere.

That’s what concerns me more than an obvious filter. I can sometimes recognize that someone’s face has been altered. It’s harder to recognize that my sense of other people has been altered due to the algorithm. Especially when I’m swiping from video to video quickly.

Maybe leaving won’t help my app grow, but staying hasn’t done much for it either. At some point I have to ask whether the possibility of being discovered is worth spending so much time at places like TikTok. I’d like people to know about and utilize what I’m making but I’d also like to put down my phone and still have faith in humanity.